Oxford university press, 1997, thomas nagel argues that the claims of reason have a certain kind of ultimacy or absolute status. Thomas nagel september 11, 2005 secular philosophy and the. Christine korsgaard 2005 danish yearbook of philosophy 40. This is the question thomas nagel raises in the last word, and the answer he gives in his subtle, compact, and forceful book is firmly and eloquently of the first kinda rationalist answer, as against answers that he variously calls subjectivist, relativist, and naturalist. Pennsylvania had the highest population of nagel families in 1840. Thomas nagel, evolutionary naturalism and the fear of religion, in the last word. In the last word, thomas nagel, one of the most influential philosophers writing in english, presents a sustained defense of reason against the attacks of. He shows that the last word in disputes about the objective validity. Introduction consider necessitationthere is a necessary connection between physical facts and mental facts.
Analytic philosophy as a historical movement has not done much to provide an alternative to the consolations of religion. Introduction to excerpt from thomas nagels the last word. Inagelsproject buhler2 antiteleologicalnaturalismissound,butthathissecularalternativeisnot very platonic or aristotelian. Nagel tackles head on current forms of relativism in logic, language, science and ethics. Nagel argues that we cannot step outside the procedures of justification and criticism employed in moral and practical reason and regard them as mere expressions of contingent local or cultural, or, even more broadly, human practices. Speaks october 24, 2006 in brain bisection and the unity of consciousness, thomas nagel suggests that data involving brain bisection calls into question the view that we can make sense of the idea of a mind, or a uni. Socratic seminar on chapter 4 of the last word by thomas nagel main ideas of argument. Thomas nagel, why we cant understand thought from the outside. Considers whether moral reasoning is fundamental and inescapable. Nov 01, 2001 the last word is a book that should be read and pondered in this golden age of relativism. Review of thomas nagel, the last word like all nagels work, this is a book with a message. Persons, brain bisection, and the unity of consciousness phil 20208 je. His target is the seemingly inexorable spread of subjectivism and relativism throughout the academy and indeed throughout philosophy itself.
Nagel, the absurd summary many are persuaded that their lives are meaningless or absurd by re. The most nagel families were found in the usa in 1880. Thomas nagel is professor of philosophy at princeton university. This was about 84% of all the recorded nagels in the usa. Reason must reflect objective principles whose validity is independent of our point of viewprinciples that anyone with enough intelligence ought to be able to recognize as correct. Buy a cheap copy of the last word book by thomas nagel. Colin mcginn, the new republic thomas nagel stands out among todays best philosophers in retaining closer links with big puzzles and mysteries that. The cosmic question teleology without theology in thomas. Perhaps nagels concerns with it have to do with his own mortality. If there is such a thing as reason, it has to be universal. There are certain specific truths which are unarguably true, and leave no room for skepticism. By thomas nagel the last word by thomas nagel if there is such a thing as reason, it has to be universal.
Resisting what he describes as the eventual demise of intellectual discourse, nagel s work sets a new standard in the debate. The last word is a book that should be read and pondered in this golden age of subjectivism. The last word by thomas nagel overdrive rakuten overdrive. The postmodernists have made subjectivism and relativism key tools in their attempt to combat the force of the enlightenment. Considering how prevalent postmodern subjectivist, relativistic, pragmatist andor naturalistic beliefs are these days, i highly recommend to pick this book and read nagel s arguments carefully. Thomas nagel has 51 books on goodreads with 26228 ratings. In this discussion of where justification and understanding come to an end, nagel undertakes to refute various forms of.
And such subjectivism is not just an inconsequential. Thomas nagel september 11, 2005 secular philosophy and. Resisting what he describes as the eventual demise of intellectual discourse, nagels work sets a new standard in the debate. The last word is a book that should be read and pondered in this golden age of relativism. You better believe it, in philosophy and public affairs 25, no. These are basic facts that are true regardless of whether people believe them or not. Thus nagel quotes rorty as saying that what kuhn, derrida and i believe is that it is pointless to ask whether there. Considering how prevalent postmodern subjectivist, relativistic, pragmatist andor naturalistic beliefs are these days, i highly recommend to pick this book and read nagels arguments carefully. Nagels opponents are not those against whom frege and husserl battled. The nagel family name was found in the usa, the uk, canada, and scotland between 1840 and 1920. Jan 05, 2002 introduction to excerpt from thomas nagels the last word introduction to excerpt from thomas nagels the last word menssen, sandra lee 20020105 00. This is sometimes made a cause for reproach, and it has led to unfavorable comparisons with the continental tradition of the twentieth. He was educated at cornell, oxford, and harvard, and taught from 1963 to 1966 at the university of. Then troes has a note describing discussions on this subject and suggested the view from nowhere by thomas nagel, for a modern.
Books the last word by thomas nagel antony flew cheers an attack on relativism by thomas nagel the substance of works by thomas nagel is always matter which matters. The last word by thomas nagel issue 20 philosophy now. Thus nagel quotes rorty as saying that what kuhn, derrida and i believe is that it is pointless to ask whether there really are mountains or whether it is merely convenient to us to talk about mountains. The good will is not good because of what it effects or accomplishes or because of its adequacy to achieve some proposed end. The fact that an organism has conscious experience at all means, basically, that there is something it is like to be that organism. Thomas nagels the last word it is frequently remarked that. The last word is a vigorous defense of reason and its universal narratives. He was educated at cornell, oxford, and harvard, and taught from 1963 to 1966 at the university of california, berkeley, before moving to princeton.
People ordinarily study philosophy only when they go to college, and i suppose that most readers will be of college age or older. In 1840 there were 31 nagel families living in pennsylvania. This latest book is a sustained polemic against subjectivist relativism. Nagel rejects bernard williamss claim that, unlike reflective theoretical reason, reflective.
My weekend read was last word, a book by philosopher thomas nagel. Books by thomas nagel author of what does it all mean. In the last word, thomas nagel, one of the most influential philosophers writing in english, presents a sustained defense of reason against the attacks of subjectivism, delivering systematic rebuttals of relativistic claims with respect to language, logic, science, and ethics. Moral luck by thomas nagel 1979 kant believed that good or bad luck should influence neither our moral judgment of a person and his actions, nor his moral assessment of himself. The last word on philosophical disputes about the objectivity of any form of thought must lie in some unqualified thoughts about how things are. Science, nagel argues, cannot explain consciousness in physical terms. Do principles of reason have objective but indeterminate validity. Colin mcginn, the new republic thomas nagel stands out among todays best philosophers in retaining closer links with big puzzles and mysteries that first attract most people to philosophy. The main line of argument he advances is rather popular. But whatever else may be said of the physical, it has to be objective. Colin mcginn, the new republic thomas nagel stands out among todays best philosophers in retaining closer links with the big puzzles and mysteries that first attract most people to philosophy. Of all published articles, the following were the most read within the past 12 months.
In 2001, nagels the last word admitted that the existence of several facets of objective reason provided problems for naturalism and evidence for theism, though he sought to undercut the latter in that book. Thomas nagels the last word is a contribution to this project of divorcing the stufy of thought from the study of thinking. He is a university professor of philosophy and law, emeritus, at new york university, where he taught from 1980 to 2016. Review of thomas nagel, the last word like all nagel s work, this is a book with a message. In the domains of logic and mathematics, certain basic propositions are immune to doubt being central to the framework of everything we can think. Pdf the view from nowhere download full pdf book download. Thomas nagel september 11, 2005 secular philosophy and the religious temperament 1. Introduction to excerpt from thomas nagels the last word introduction to excerpt from thomas nagels the last word menssen, sandra lee 20020105 00. But this generality of reason is what relativists and subjectivists deny in everincreasing numbers. Speaks october 24, 2006 in brain bisection and the unity of consciousness, thomas nagel suggests that data involving brain bisection calls into question the view that we can make sense. Thomas nagel s the last word is a defense of reason and objectivity against the claims of subjectivism, socalled perspectivalism and relativism. His overall argument is that project of criticising reason is selfdefeating. The cosmic question teleology without theology in thomas nagel. Dr nagel 1937 is professor of philosophy and law at new york university.
Socratic seminar the last word nagel1 socratic seminar on. In the last word, thomas nagel argues against what he calls subjectivism, a general tendency to reduce the objective pretensions of reason. Obviously it does not apply just to what can be described by the concepts of contemporary physics, since we expect further developments. Tyler doggett university of vermont and daniel stoljar anu 1. His main areas of philosophical interest are legal philosophy, political philosophy, and ethics. The last word hardcover thomas nagel oxford university. Like all nagels work, this is a book with a message. The message is that there is a limit to the extent to which we can get outside fundamental forms of thought, including logical, mathematical, scientific and ethical thought. Our reading is nagels 1974 article what is it like to be a bat. Inthe last wordthe book from which our text is excerptednagel defends universal reason against rela tivists and subjectivists, and argues that public. Philosophy 5topics in recent and contemporary philosophy. Persons, brain bisection, and the unity of consciousness. Another 59 words 4 lines of text covering the years 1689, 1757, 1830, 1508, 1536, 1541, 1719, 1784, 1636, 1699, 1686, 1691 and 1689 are included under the topic early nagel history in all our pdf extended history products and printed products wherever possible. Thomas nagel s the last word is a contribution to this project of divorcing the stufy of thought from the study of thinking.
399 1239 78 759 337 293 1162 948 545 1215 259 1275 1530 1336 731 1373 878 995 147 1075 1051 1225 912 27 1164 184 714 320 71