The furnace heat exchanger is the one of the main components inside the gas furnace and its used to transfer the heat from the. He pulls off the panel, shoves a mirror inside and takes a quick 10 second peek before confirming his diagnosis that it is in fact a cracked heat exchanger and that the unit will need to be replaced. A cracked heat exchanger allows air from the furnace blower to interfere with the flame causing it to flutter or even roll out. Taking a reading is a lot faster then checking the hx visually, and although it wont tell you for sure that there is a crack, it can usually tell you if there isnt. After analysis had been performed, the crack in the tube strongly indicate that stress corrosion cracking was occurred by chloride. Find them too often, and your company could get a rep for using scare tactics. Pdf repair of tubetubesheet weld cracks in a cracked. Heat exchanger crack finder solution, heat exchanger.
The following are various procedures and test methods to tell how to identify a cracked furnace heat exchanger. Furnace is not safe combustion analysis is the heat. The tubular ones will crack on the outlet near the inducer motor or on the curves themselves. Heat exchanger cracks are worth finding but they arent the most dangerous issue for your customers in most cases. He based this on performing a carbon monoxide test over 10 ppm detected near the boiler hood and evidence of acidic condensate dustsootwhatever on the top of the boiler by the hood.
I definitely have a cracked primary heat exchanger and will be replacing our furnace. That you can test for carbon monoxide at the register if there is a crack in the heat exchanger. The furnace is a carrier thatunder a settlementcarrier agreed to either pay the labor and parts to replace the secondary heat exchanger, including labor, or to give a credit to a new furnace installation. Induceddraft furnace heat exchanger inspection procedure. Failure analysis of tubetubesheet welds in cracked gas heat. The heat exchanger on a furnace is the section that keeps the combustion chamber and the breathing air separate 3. One of the oldest ways to check for heat exchanger cracks is to simply observe the flame when the blower starts. For the clamshell heat exchanger, the most accurate test is the leak test. Symptoms of a cracked secondary heat exchanger carrier. You know its serious and you know you need to do something about it. Dec 02, 2015 proper diagnosis of a failed or cracked heat exchanger. I wrote a blog post many years ago discussing that topic, and the gist of my blog post was the same as whats stated on the comyths web site. Its not that youre questioning their credibility, youre just wanted to see for yourself.
Diagnosis of a heat exchanger crack typically starts with a noheat service call. A damaged heat exchanger in a gas furnace is potentially dangerous to a homes occupants and should not be ignored. We use it to check co levels given in parts per million, or ppm and determine for sure whether theres a crack in your heat exchanger. The tracer gas test all openings in the heat exchanger are sealed, a methane tracer gas is injected into the heat exchanger. Heat exchanger leak detection plate dyetesting wcr 100% dyetesting is our standard for locating cracks, pinholes, or failures.
Popped rings or cracked faceplates on a lot of models. Call around to find someone else to replace the exchanger. Ceo to make a glass cover that would protect the iphone from scratches and cracks. The american gas association has even put this in writing they say any visible crack or hole is reason for requiring replacement of the heat exchanger or furnace. Residential gas furnace heat exchanger testing douglas dewerth, p. The test mostoften used to determine if theres a problem with the clamshell or sectional heat exchanger is called a candle test. Proper diagnosis of a failed or cracked heat exchanger. I sent a short answer, but thought this was deserving of a longer answer in the form of a blog post. Its like the doctor that finds cancer it might not be good news, but it. Combustion test to determine if the heat exchanger is cracked. Check your device for damage that isnt covered by the warranty, whether youve dropped it, kicked it, or drop kicked it into a river. So on the lennox duracurve heat exchanger its on the bottom curve in the back. If they say its not a visible crack, but they have a co detection device that found a crack, ask them to show you.
Other air leaks in the vicinity of the burners may also cause flame disturbances and. One of the most common reasons a gas furnace can be taken out of service, is when the repair technician finds to a cracked heat exchanger. Fire up a welder, and use the liquid metal to form a gluelike line around the edge of your sheet metal. The prevailing viewpoint is that any hole or or heat exchanger crack can and will get larger and when it does, it is an immediate. Will a cracked heat exchanger leak carbon monoxide. Sometimes the co reading will increase not because the he is cracked, but because the air filer bracket doesnt have a cover and its drawing fumes back through the burners. Mar 19, 2007 the pressure test all openings in the heat exchanger are sealed, the blower energized, and a pressure sensor or draft gauge is inserted inside the heat exchanger to see if a crack is allowing distribution air to blow into the heat exchanger through a crack or hole. In order for this to happen, the furnace must be producing high levels of carbon monoxide and the exhaust gas must be mixing with the household air. How to check a heat exchanger for a leak diy furnace. If it is your heat exchanger, you cannot run your furnace, even if it. The pressure test all openings in the heat exchanger are sealed, the blower energized, and a pressure sensor or draft gauge is inserted inside the heat exchanger to see if a crack is allowing distribution air to blow into the heat exchanger through a crack or hole. A heat exchanger is a heat management system that uses fluids to transfer heat from one medium to the other.
When a heat exchanger becomes damaged and the combustion fumes and gases mix with the clean air. Place an x in the box next to each item as you perform the test. According to cornings own tests, gorilla glass scratch resistance hasnt. As the heat exchanger heats up from the burners, there is a heat transfer from the metal to the supply air as it travels past the heat exchanger. Other than this, there really isnt anything else that can definitively give you an answer. Flame rollout from a blocked heat exchanger, gas furnace duration. Visual detection, cameras, or detectors with marginal coverage. Miss a cracked heat exchanger and you put the homeowners at risk. Phe cracks can be dangerously costly to your business. Pdf repair of tubetubesheet weld cracks in a cracked gas.
He or she can use a combustion gas analyzer to determine if it is your heat exchanger or not. Once you are ready to begin the repair itself, put on your safety glasses and gloves. The american gas association has even put this in writing they say any visible crack or hole is reason. How to check the heat exchanger of a furnace quora.
A cracked heat exchanger may leak co in a small stream. Read our blog to learn what to do if this happens to you. If there is outofwarranty damage, unfortunately the mobile expert wont be able to complete the exchange. He said that in his experience, the presence of these two things always means the heat exchanger is cracked. Dec 22, 2010 if you have a cracked heat exchanger you should also be noticing more moisture in the house, with marked increase in moisture condensing on the cold surfaces like windows. If a properly conducted heat exchanger test shows a cracked heat exchanger, the repair person is to red tag and shut off the furnace as this will result in death of occupants. Cracked heat exchanger revgen 4 summitfreeride 850. The author has been in the industry for years as a trainer for hvac technicians. One way that is probably still used today is to turn off the gas valve, turn the thermostat all the way down and to fan on and t.
The combustion analyzer also helps us gauge the overall performance of your furnace. Carbon monoxide and heat exchangers november 02, 2018 carbon monoxide, the poisonous, colorless, odorless and tasteless gas responsible for more than 20,000 visits to the emergency room every year, can pose a danger from unforeseen sources in your home. A combustion analyzer gives us co and oxygen readings. Mar 10, 2016 how to identify an unsafe furnace with a possible cracked heat exchanger with a combustion analysis. It is only 4 years old, but the heater just failed. The exhaust gases from the crack are not diluted too much before coming in contact with the sensor. For gas packs a company that does commercial accounts might be the better choice. Expert express plumbing heating and air conditioning. A co detector cannot tell you if a heat exchanger is good.
Heat exchangers wa have an exceptionally reliable and versatile crack detection service, able to test the largest of plates and deliver the most accurate possible results. At its outset, a cracked heat exchanger is a problem that will go unnoticed by most homeowners. If you are not sure if you fall in our service area, check out our service area. Why your brandnew smartphone will scratch just as easily as your. The heat exchanger is a key part of the furnace and is responsible for the actual heating of air. However, the current mind set in the industry is that every heat exchanger crack is dangerous. The tracer gas test all openings in the heat exchanger are sealed, a methane tracer gas is injected into the heat exchanger, and a combustible gas leak detector passed around the outside looking for areas where the. Signs and symptoms of a cracked gas furnace heat exchanger. Aga and gama insist that even a hairline crack in a heat exchanger constitutes a defect and requires replacement. If you have a steel exchanger, then cut down a piece of sheet metal to cover the crack, plus 2 inches all the way around.
Every cracked heat exchanger needs to be replaced, either by replacing the heat exchanger itself or by replacing the entire furnace. If i find that both heat exchangers failed, i can get the credit. Carbon monoxide and heat exchangers service experts. Common signs of a crack were getting close to discovering the answers behind the heat exchanger mystery. The first step is simply to look where most homeowners cant. Combustion check to confirm cracked heat exchanger youtube. You may measure high concentrations only an inch away. I have seen cases where the fire is blown out from a crack in the heat exchanger, or where the fire has extra air and burns very very erratically. The cause of the failure has been analyzed, and the. There are other test gases that have been or continue to be used to test furnace heat exchangers for leaks. Diagnosis of a heat exchanger crack typically starts with a no heat service call. Expert express plumbing heating and air conditioning 30,943 views. Then after the season hes going to weld a patch on the crack. Older furnaces can develop major issues, such as a cracked heat exchanger.
Please read this article about why heat exchanger cracks do not allow carbon monoxide into the house. Unless you are one of the top 3% of people who have all the money, replacing the furnace is going to hurt the pocket book if you have not planed for it, but it has to be done. If your repairman claims to have found a crack in your heat exchanger, insist on seeing the crack for yourselfparticularly if it took very little time for the repair technician to make the. Well had something come up and cracked the front heat exchanger on my 19 summit 154 took to dealer its been there 2 days keep telling me they are waiting for brp to get back to them on parts availability. Shellandtube heat exchanger is a user friendly program which for a given heat exchanger initial conditions and geometry predicts outlet temperatures of both shellside and tubeside fluids, heat. The inspector infrared video inspection camera allows you to clearly see the holes, cracks, rust, or corrosion damage inside any furnace. If someone informs you that your heat exchanger is cracked, call the tedder. The tracer gas test all openings in the heat exchanger are sealed. However, professional hvac technicians always check heat exchangers for damage during their preseason maintenance inspection. Javascript must be enabled in order for you to use this site. This is a total waste of time in most cases because the blower motor of a residential furnace is positive and the combustion side of the heat exchanger is a negative, the much more powerful.
It is important that the heat exchanger is taken care of as hazards can build from a faulty exchanger. May 12, 2000 miss a cracked heat exchanger and you put the homeowners at risk. How to identify an unsafe furnace with a possible cracked heat exchanger with a combustion analysis. Simple furnace heat exchanger test hvac learning solutions. Its the best way to examine your heat exchanger for cracks. Ways to check for cracked heat exchangers a combustion analyzer is an awesome tool and this is only part of what its good for. Its not unlike a doctor telling you about the c word. If its older than 10 to 12 years old, you may want to go with replacing the entire furnace. If theres a crack in this component, the gases being burned off, such as carbon monoxide, sulfur dioxide, and nitrous oxide, could leak into your home, causing illness or, in extreme cases, death. Dec 02, 2014 i recently had a reader email this question. Dont know what to do,anybody have any luck welding or patching them dont want to lose the rest of the. Some people choose to live in denial of the seriousness of a cracked heat exchanger. The cause of cracked heat exchangers avoid this common scam. It describes most of the available tests and has images of some of the testing tools and methods of how to check for a cracked heat exchanger.
Click here to see a cracked gas furnace heat exchanger. Combustion test to determine if the heat exchanger is cracked duration. How do you guys diagnose cracked or bad heat exchangers. Our home inspector says the heat exchanger is not covered in a home inspection. Pdf risk based inspection of gascooling heat exchanger. From what ive been told and read, it could mean that my heat exchanger is cracked. Serious cracks were found at tubetotubesheet welds during the start up operation of a cracked gassteam heat exchanger in a gas plant. Cracked heat exchanger introduction to the lesson this example simulates the stress concentration due to a crack formed between two layers in a heat exchanger pipe. Due to high demand for nucalgon heat exchanger crack finder solution, heat exchanger inspection system, availability is subject to change without notice. I noticed the other day the my how water boiler had flames dancing around underneath the heat exchanger. In the video above the furnace techs says the oxygen reading could rise as high as 4050% if the heat exchanger is cracked. If you have a cracked heat exchanger you should also be noticing more moisture in the house, with marked increase in moisture condensing on the cold surfaces like windows.
Located in the center of the furnace, it is where fire, gas and heat connect. Expert express plumbing heating and air conditioning 31,784 views. Most cracks will be where there is a curve in the metal. A heat exchanger is made of thin metal, and as it heats up from the combustion of the furnace, it transfers the heat to the air being distributed through the house by the blower 3. Broken and leaking heat exchangers are responsible for about 1,500 deaths per year in the united states, and many more people are poisoned by exposure to toxic gasses that go unfiltered by defective heat exchangers. A co detector can indicate a heat exchanger is cracked or perforated only if all of the following conditions occur simultaneously. Enough exhaust gases are emitted from the heat exchanger crack or. Heat exchangers plate heat exchanger crack detection test. Nowadays, checking for a cracked heat exchanger is way more scientific. We use it to check co levels given in parts per million, or ppm and determine for sure whether theres a crack in. Failure analysis of tubetubesheet welds in cracked gas. In most systems there is negative pressure on the inside of the exchanger driven by the inducer motor. Furnace heatexchanger crack signs your furnace has one. Bobs answer to whether or not a cracked heat exchanger can be dangerous is unambiguous.
If a crack in the heat exchanger occurs, then it becomes possible for the carbon monoxide to seep into the supply air system. Mar 11, 20 our recommendation on finding a crack in a heat exchanger will always be to replace the heat exchanger or the furnace it is in because your familys health and safety is far too important to make guesses and assumptions about how dangerous this crack may or may not be. The heating contractor found a crack in the heat exchanger. With proprietary red dyepenetrant saturating the plate surface, and white developer solution covering the reverse side, wcr is capable of detecting even miniscule imperfections. Dec 12, 2014 combustion test to determine if the heat exchanger is cracked duration. A salt spray test is a test for heat exchanger cracks, its conducted by disconnecting the blower motor power wire so it will not run. This test involves spraying the outside of the heat exchanger with a watersurfactant solution and then looking on the inside to see if it has leaked through.
Metallurgical failure analysis and metal corrosion testing and investigation can help. Have you heard this one recently, you have a cracked heat exchanger and your furnace has to be replaced, today. If it has, anyone conducting this test is 100% certain a crack exists. When the the cycle stops, i dont hear any hissing after which could mean water leaking out of the exchanger.
Inspect for common heat exchanger leak, crack, or rust points. This test should be performed by a trained hvac technician. When faced with that decision, something to consider is the age of your unit. Its the worlds first and leading heat exchanger video inspection camera, with an infrared, highresolution camera mounted on a 37inch wand that is attached to its very own display monitor. So whats a cracked heat exchanger all about and whats the big deal. He is a welder and chose to go this route to get him going for the rest of the season. Often the co reading will decrease when there is a crack or hole in the heat exchanger. There are older, traditional ways for finding cracked heat exchangers, such as smoke bomb methods, which contractors have relied on for years. Assuming you are talking about a residential furnace. The final part of our investigation is knowing the signs and dangers of a cracked heat exchanger. Heat exchanger leak detection plate dyetesting wcr. Since glass cant truly be both extremely drop resistant and scratch. What are some tell tale signs of a cracked heat exchanger.
If your heat exchanger is most likely the issue, its time to call in a professional. If the heat exchanger is cracked, the meter will show us. On one furnace i even seen the flames coming out of the heat exchanger and burning the wires and controls that in effect control the gas and furnace. Can you repair a cracked heat exchanger on a gas furnace. Avoid these 4 common furnace repair scams oconomowoc boiler. The concern is that a cracked heat exchanger could allow exhaust gas from the furnace to contaminate the household air with carbon monoxide. There are other test gases that have been or continue to be used to test furnace heat. This contractortalk forum entry is a compilation of a number of heat exchanger tests that can be used to identify a cracked fire box or if a heat exchanger has holes. Before we accept an apple device, make sure find my iphone fmip is disabled.
To test for cracks using a combustion analyzer, simply watch the o2co2 readings and the co reading when the blower comes on usually. Aga has described a test gas mixture of nitrogenmethane inserted into a plugged heat exchanger also may require disassembly in some cases. Theres a lot of good info on there, but some of it is misleading and there are a lot of straw man arguments made. Failure analysis of tubetubesheet welds in cracked gas heat exchangers. Common myths regarding furnace heat exchangers youtube. There are cameras available that can slide in and give a view. If a crack has developed, air from the house will be forced into the combustion chamber when the blower turns on, causing some visible disturbance of the flame, he says. Replacing a heat exchanger takes time and knowledge that some dont have. A customer of mine sucked up a rock into the heat exchanger of his summit 850. A cracked heat exchanger in a gas furnace is a serious safety issue. A cracked heat exchanger is pretty serious, as far as safety for your home goes. This trips a safety switch and shuts down the furnace. The flame generates enough co lack of oxygen, excess fuel, high temperature. Jan 24, 2019 page 1 of 2 cracked heat exchanger posted in revgen 4 summitfreeride 850 turbo.
1482 425 880 457 229 592 500 45 1225 560 195 902 499 823 730 1294 1126 56 1420 944 1492 715 1022 334 1572 108 834 1398 243 884 550 623 1156 1165 1413 514 164 788